Ralph, abbot of Arbroath, Hugh, abbot of St Serf's (Culross Abbey), Innocent, abbot of Inchaffray, Peter, abbot of Cambuskenneth, Gilbert the archdeacon, and all clergy of diocese of Dunblane, ratify agreement between Dunblane Cathedral and Lindores Abbey, by arbitral of Sir William, bishop of St Andrews, concerning dispute between parties over church of Muthill (PER), as contained in authentic instrument and established by Sir William, bishop of Glasgow and his colleagues, on authority of Pope, and as accepted with assent by Sir Clement, bishop of Dunblane.
16 April 1235 X 17 June 1239
shortly after 7/May/1235
Sentence of papal judges × election of Ralph, abbot of Arbroath, to bishopric of Aberdeen, prob. shortly after _Lindores Chartulary_, no. 51