Henry, earl of Atholl, for Dunfermline Abbey; he has granted, and by his charter established, to Dunfermline Abbey the donation Earl Mael Coluim his father made to them of the church of Moulin (PER), with three ploughgates of land, namely, 'Petduuedi', 'Petmaldoic', 'Balchonene', 'Petmacdufgille' (PER).
1189 X 7 January 1210
perhaps circa 1198 ×
Thomas of Galloway was earl of Atholl by 7 Jan. 1210 (_RRS_, ii, no. 489). Henry only witnessed one royal charter, _RRS_, ii, no. 403 (5 Sept., 1198 × 1203, prob. 1198). Malcolm's last attestations of royal charters date to 1178×95 (_RRS_, ii, no. 278), 1187×90, perhaps 1187 (_RRS_, ii, no. 273), 1183×1195 (_RRS_, ii, no. 274) and 1175×90 (_RRS_, ii, no. 271). Malcolm was still alive in 1189, as he witnessed a charter of Bishop John of Dunkeld dated 1189×1203 (_Dunf. Reg._, no. 126). Barrow says Henry began term circa 1198 but he could have become earl any time after 1189.